Wednesday, February 26, 2014

February 26, 2014

Several of the local Starbucks shops have removed comfortable seating and substituted tables and hard chairs. Perhaps this is meant to cater to the business-meeting or laptop clientele, or maybe some people lingered too long. Whatever the reason, it has limited my options, as I’m an easy-chair type. My usual choice these days is a shop next to a Safeway, which leads to the following observations during a visit in December. For some reason I didn’t inflict them on the web at the time but, though stale, they still are relevant, if not especially important or original.
Perhaps because I tend to be a pessimist — although I prefer to attribute my attitude to being unusually perceptive — I harbor thoughts about cultural decline. (Actually, I find it puzzling that anyone over the age of forty could not be aware of that development, but never mind). There are so many significant indicia of that trend that the following examples will seem trivial, but here they are anyway:
The story begins at the gym (sorry: fitness center) I use twice weekly. It provides towels (small) for mopping the brow and semi-large — large by the standards of the underfunded organization — for showers. The drill is to toss them, when used, into bins provided for the purpose. Instead, a growing number of those frequenting the men’s locker room drop them on the floor, leave them on benches or in showers or stuff them into lockers, anything to avoid the ordeal of carrying them twenty feet (on the way out) to the bin near the door.
After my workout, I stopped at Starbucks. When I left there, I found several carts from the adjacent Safeway abandoned on the sidewalk, some distance away from the grocery store, which is in the opposite direction, and nowhere near any of the return areas. Proceeding toward my car, I spotted a parking slot covered with trash: cups, napkins and other bits of paper; someone had cleaned out his (messy) car and left the debris for someone else to clean up.
Back to the gym: while riding the stationary bike, I glanced at one of the tv monitors which, as usual, displayed Fox "News." Actually, it was Fox Business "News," but no matter. There was no sound, but a display at the bottom of the screen asked whether the wealth gap really is a problem. Those who can ask, and more so those who deny it, are of the same class as those who litter and abandon carts. The smug and comfortable and their admirers may not dump trash on the ground, but they are soul mates to those who do: both are of the I’m-more-important-than-my-fellow-man, let-the-little-people-cope sort.

Sunday, February 23, 2014

February 23, 2014

Some reports show that viewership of television news is declining. If NBC Nightly News is typical, that’s not surprising. Hard news makes up little of any broadcast, and commentary or context rarely appear, even when the story screams for it, as with climate change. 
NBC has taken another step down. It is broadcasting the evening news from Sochi, for no apparent reason other than to promote the network’s exclusive coverage of the Olympic Games. Also, the program devoted sections of two broadcasts last week to the advent of Jimmy Fallon as host of the Tonight Show, also an NBC program: news as corporate advertisement.
A clip from a Conan O’Brien show is circulating on the web which demonstrates the vapid, insubstantial, derivative nature of local television news. It shows twenty-four news "anchors" delivering the same "report’ about shopping for oneself at Christmas: "It’s OK, you can admit it, if you bought an item or two, or ten, for yourself."[18]1 The origin of the script isn’t revealed, but it is identical, a few fluffs and variations aside, on each broadcast. It’s amusing to watch the newsreaders emote in an attempt to convert a handout into something original, but it’s another indication of how badly we are served by news media.
Are voters uninformed? Considering that the alternative to right-wing propaganda on Fox is self-promotion or inanity on other channels, it is not surprising.
________________
 
18. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TM8L7bdwVaA

Sunday, February 16, 2014

February 16, 2014

I haven’t written anything for a while. It is not a limitation of material that poses the challenge. It is that one can say that the world is going to hell in only so many ways, and that saying so repeatedly, even with variations, even with new instances, convinces the reader that the writer is obsessive and therefore unreliable, to say nothing of boring. However, . . .
Last month I ran out of anything to read — actually, there were several books waiting to be read, but nothing I was in a mood for (shouldn’t end a phrase with a preposition) — so, for no specific reason, I took from the shelf The Collapse of the Third Republic, William L. Shirer’s account of the fall of France in the Second World War. It is in part a history of the defeat in 1940 but also of the weaknesses of French politics and society — back to 1871 — which led to that result. When I read it the first time, years ago, I probably thought that the French were a hopeless lot with an exceptionally dysfunctional culture and government. Now some of their problems seem uncomfortably like ours. Reading The Collapse led me to reread part of Tony Judt’s The Burden of Responsibility, which discusses three French thinkers, notably Léon Blum, Premier of France in the Thirties. It reenforced the impression that we are on a road traveled before.
Take, for example, the attitude toward business, wealth and taxes. In early Twentieth Century France, Shirer tells us, "the entrepreneurs convinced themselves to an extent that today seems highly amusing that they were operating a free market open equally to all and that they owed their success and their profits to the virtues of the ‘free-enterprise’ system, which rewarded those with imagination, initiative, and ‘know-how’ who were brave enough to take risks."[1]  That may have been amusing in 1969, when The Collapse was published, and when we seemingly had learned better, but now it simply describes us equally well.
In the Twenties, French governments, facing fiscal disaster, "declined to do anything at all, even to face their problems." France had just emerged from World War I. The parallel to the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan hardly is perfect, but there are similarities in attitude and policy: "Instead of raising taxes the government raised loans, a habit it had acquired during the war, when taxes. . . were scarcely augmented despite the dire necessity." We went further, and cut taxes while waging war. "It seemed obvious that taxes would have to be raised and some financial sacrifices made by those best able to afford them. But this did not seem obvious to Parliament,"[2] nor has it to Congress.
Parliament, like Congress, did not operate in a vacuum; the attitude of the wealthy controlled. "The selfishness of the moneyed class in avoiding any financial sacrifice to help put the country back on its feet later struck many French historians as shocking. The possessors and the manipulators of most of the country's wealth simply contrived to escape shouldering a fair share of the burden of paying for the war and the reconstruction."[3]  Capital was stashed abroad. Rebuilding after the devastation of WWI was a greater challenge than our recession and our crumbling infrastructure, but attitudes are strikingly similar. Again, the surprise of historians was felt years ago.
We hear cries from many on the right that taxation is theft, that it’s their money, not the government’s, that they can use it so much more productively. That, too, is an echo. A member of the Chamber of Deputies pointed out a truism of taxation, "you have to take the money from where it is," to no avail. "The answer of the business and financial interests was given in the Chamber by one of their spokesmen . . . : ‘We are told you have to take the money from where it is. I maintain that first you have to leave it where it is.' And that is where it was left."[4]
In addition to the self-interest of the wealthy, a lack of understanding or acceptance of economic truths hampered efforts. "Ignorance of economics on both the Right and the Left played a role in compounding the mess. On the Right, bankers and businessmen were trying to apply classic nineteenth-century capitalist doctrines to the twentieth century, whose problems, were much more complex. On the Left most of the politicians . . . had little comprehension of the problems of financing a state . . . ."[5]  Our ignorance, or refusal, is the more reprehensible because the self-defeating theories we cling to have been disproved by experience.
The refusal to learn is more general, sometimes amounting a disdain for modernity, a rejection of science, of facts. Judt described France’s "nostalgic denial," the "propensity for preserving the past in the face of a threatening present."[6] Republican presidential candidates must proclaim that they disbelieve in evolution, and the right denounces climate change as a hoax.
There is a parallel also in the attitude of many toward the head of government. Léon Blum was the leader of the Socialist party, and Premier for a year during the critical Thirties. He was vilified, partly for his policies, but primarily because has was a Jew. "How, his enemies howled, could such a man represent French interests?" He was not a real Frenchman. The prospect of Blum’s actually becoming prime minister was too much. "Your arrival, Mr. Prime Minister, is without question a historic date," he was told in the Chamber of Deputies. "For the first time this ancient Gallo-Roman land is to be ruled by a Jew. . . ."[7]   We have copied this ploy: destroy a political enemy by making him the Other. Jews and blacks certainly have been the classic Others, and now Muslims have been added to the list, so Obama also is a Muslim. Blum was denounced for putting Jews in the Cabinet; Obama is "an avowed racist" for expressing sympathy for Trayvon Martin.
If merely categorizing by race or religion is not enough, add the claim that the Other is a foreigner. In one story, Blum was accused of being a Bulgarian, but that was too mild: "The prime minister, coming from a wandering race, dumped in the Ile-de-France by a chance that might as easily have deposited him in New York, Cairo, or Vilna, [is] the leader of a people foreign to his flesh."[8] Obama, of course, is a Kenyan. "How [Blum] hates us! He resents us for everything: for our blue sky and our soft air, for our peasants who walk in clogs across French soil and whose ancestors were not camel dealers, wandering in the Syrian desert with his Palestinian friends. . . ."[9]   Obama "has no idea how the American system functions, and we shouldn’t be surprised about that, because he spent his early years in Hawaii smoking something, spent the next set of years in Indonesia . . . ."[10]  In contrast to the Republican "course for the country," Obama’s "course is extraordinarily foreign."[11]
Nor only foreign, but sinister. "Between France and this cursed man, we must choose. He is the very incarnation of everything that sickens our flesh and our blood. He is evil. He is death."[12]  As with Blum so with Obama. According to a 2013 poll "20 percent of Republicans said they believed Obama is the Antichrist, while only [!] 6 percent of Democrats agree."[13]  On quieter days, he is merely (and simultaneously) a communist and a fascist.
Reactions become violent. A right-wing publisher declared of Blum, "Here is "a man to shoot down, but in the back . . . human detritus who should be treated as such."[14]  Obama is a "communist raised communist educated communist nurtured subhuman mongrel" and "gangster" and should be punished for treason.[15]  Or shot: a Christian American Patriots Militia leader announced in 2013, "We now have authority to shoot Obama, i.e., to kill him. His willful violations and alienation of our Constitution, . . . and corruption of all the three branches of government . . . reveal the dictator that he is."[16]  At a town hall meeting in February of this year, a Republican Congressman carried on a chat with a woman in the audience who had announced that Obama "should be executed as an enemy combatant." The Congressman either agreed with her or saw nothing unusual in her rant.[17]
The Third Republic had come into being more or less by accident in 1871, and those on the right — monarchists, the military, business and the clergy — never accepted it, and wanted to bring it down. That sentiment persisted until World War II, exacerbated by right-wing admiration for fascism. Nothing on that scale has developed here, but we see manifestations of a similarly destructive attitude. Republicans in Congress shut down the government and threaten to destroy its creditworthiness, partly to gain specific ends, partly because they dislike it and its president. The tone was set in January, 2009 by party leader Limbaugh — "I hope he fails" — and Republican have reflexively opposed nearly everything Obama has supported, even a conservative health care plan. Nullifiers and other states-righters want to weaken the federal government, allowing the states to be (more) reactionary. Many see tyranny in every attempt to improve life; some dream of replacing the government with a regime of their own. Gun nuts want to turn the country into an armed society, every nut his own posse. When something awful happens, such as 9-11, or the Boston Marathon bombing, or the Newtown shooting, conspiracy theorists claim it’s a "false flag" operation, something perpetrated by the government. These are not healthy trends.
Any parallel to France is, of course, ironic, as the American right is so disdainful of that land; how embarrassing to be like it.

________________________

1.
The Collapse of the Third Republic, p. 78.2. All quotes in this paragraph Id., at 153
3. Id., at 154
4. Ibid
5. Id., at 160
6. The Burden of Responsibility, p. 8
7. Id., at 75-76
8. Id., at 76
9. Id., at 77
11. According to Mitt Romney. http://thinkprogress.org/politics/2012/07/17/537131/how-romney-spent-all-day-calling-obama-a-foreigner/ 12. The Burden of Responsibility, p. 77
13. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/04/03/americans-believe-obama-anti-christ-global-warming-hoax_n_3008558.html
14. The Burden of Responsibility, p. 76
15. So saith Ted Nugent (lack of punctuation in the original report). http://mediamatters.org/blog/2014/01/21/outdoor-channels-ted-nugent-says-subhuman-mongr/197669
16. The article cites other threats. http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/11/25/christian-american-patriots-militia-leader-we-now-have-authority-to-shoot-obama/
17. http://talkingpointsmemo.com//livewire/congressman-cordial-chat-execute-obama

Thursday, January 9, 2014

January 8 , 2014

The new year produced some interesting opinion pieces.

In The Washington Post Ruth Marcus headed her December 31 column "Edward Snowden, the insufferable whistle blower." That aptly described her view, which is that Snowden is personally repulsive. "Insufferable is the first adjective evoked by Snowden’s recent interview with Barton Gellman in The Post, but it has numerous cousins: smug, self-righteous, egotistical, disingenuous, megalomaniacal, over-wrought." That is an oddly-focused reading of Gellman’s interview and of the situation. After all, the important issue is whether Snowden’s disclosures harmed or helped the country. Snowden maintains the latter, and apparently Gellman does as well, as he aided in the release of the secret information. Ms. Marcus hinted at a substantive issue — "Not for Snowden any anxiety about the implications for national security of his theft of government secrets" — but only as part of the discussion of his character which continued for several more paragraphs.
Eventually addressing the core question, she conceded problems with the surveillance program but concluded, on no obvious grounds, that oversight isn’t as weak as claimed, the degree of invasion of privacy isn’t all that serious, the NSA folk have been truthful as to the limited nature of their snooping, and national security has been compromised by the disclosures.
Odd that she didn’t condemn Gellman, and her paper, for aiding and abetting.
The New York Times, in its house editorial of January 2, concluded that Snowden "was clearly justified" in believing that the only way to expose overreach was to leak documents. It recommended clemency: "Considering the enormous value of the information he has revealed, Mr. Snowden deserves better than a life of permanent exile, fear and flight."
Jonathan Capehart, Ms. Marcus’ colleague at the Post, reacted to that suggestion by essentially repeating her remarks. In a column on January 2 captioned "No clemency from Snowden’s self-importance," he too concentrated on his personal disdain for Snowden and quoted Marcus’ list of synonyms for "insufferable." He acknowledged some merit in Snowden’s argument but in effect conditioned clemency on gagging Snowden because he is just too smug. Their approach seems to be an extreme instance of elevating style over substance.
__________________
On January 1 the Times ran a column by Michael Moore on another controversial topic: health care. He made no attempt to defend Obamacare as a policy choice, with good reason. It was "conceived at the Heritage foundation, . . . birthed in Massachusetts by Mitt Romney," and adopted by Obama, who apparently hoped that conservatives would not attack their own offspring. Moore acknowledged that it is better than nothing, but thinks that states should go further, by adding a public option or, as proposed in Vermont, a single-payer system. Given the paralysis in Congress, that may be the only way forward.
__________________
On January 1, in a column on Truthout entitled "The Year of the Gun," William Rivers Pitt presented a litany of deaths by gunfire. The most appalling category is the death of children, by accident, from guns left lying around. He cited a study showing that "each year approximately 7,500 children are admitted to U.S. hospitals with gunshot wounds and more than 500 children die during hospital admission from these injuries." Another Truthout article on January 2 pointed out the increasing militarization of police — think of all the clips of SWAT teams with assault rifles — and its contribution to our gun culture.

Wednesday, December 11, 2013

December 11, 2013
A few days after Christmas in 2011, I listed several measures of our economy which demonstrated that the pre-redemption Scrooge would be right at home in twenty-first century America. I won’t revisit the entire list, but it’s clear that the situation has not changed, at least not for the better.
At that time, the six Walton heirs possessed wealth equal to the total wealth of the bottom thirty percent of the American population; now it’s forty-two per cent.[142]   The six own about half the stock of Walmart, which continues to support its, and their, exalted financial position by paying its employees substandard wages. That was dramatically illustrated by a photo of a donation box in an Ohio Walmart, asking employees (associates) to "donate food items so associates in need can enjoy Thanksgiving dinner." Apparently that is not the only Walmart conducting such a drive, and no wonder: like McDonald’s’s and other prosperous large companies, Walmart pays its "associates" very little, one reason that the company had a profit of $15.7 billion in 2011. It did manage to give its CEO a compensation package of $17.6 million, so it isn’t entirely heartless. (His compensation was 796 times that of the average employee).[143]
By one measure, one in six Americans lives in poverty.[144]  Whatever the exact number, this is a disgrace, a moral outrage, and a national failure. As an article in The Nation put it, referring to homelessness and food stamp cuts, "In a minimally functioning political system, there would be a debate about potential solutions to these unfolding disasters."[145]
Conservatives tell us, repeatedly, that we are a Christian nation. Shouldn’t we then rally around efforts to help the poor? Isn’t that in the spirit of Christianity? Well, no, according to many amateur theologians on the right. Rep. Stephen Fincher (R-TN) supported cuts to SNAP (food stamps) by citing 2 Thessalonians 3:10: "For even when we were with you, we gave you this command: Anyone unwilling to work should not eat."[146]  One of his colleagues, Rep. Kevin Cramer (R-ND), hid behind the same passage.[147]  Leaving aside whether they took the quote out of context — and the consensus of those who can speak with authority appears to be that they did — how does it apply to children, the elderly, the disabled and the large segment of recipients who are, in fact, employed? It is simply an excuse, an offensive excuse, for playing the I’ve-got-mine game, which seems to form the core of Republican politics.
Using Christianity to defend such attitudes is not confined to members of Congress. According to Ken Blackwell of the Family Research Council, there is "nothing more Christian" than "not locking people into a permanent dependency on government handouts, but making sure they are participants in their own upliftment and empowerment so that they in fact through the dignity of work and can break from the plantation of big government." In true reactionary spirit, he would privatize charity: "We are not lacking in churches in church communities across this nation in making sure that basic human needs are met without creating another government program that establishes rules that have very low expectations for self-discipline."[148] Is private charity adequate to the task? Of course not, but never mind. Tony Perkins, also of the Family Research Council, can’t find a relevant text: ". . .the government has a responsibility to care for the poor? That’s not what the Scripture says."[149]
Gary Bauer, President of American Values and a self-described evangelical Christian, asserts that "nowhere in the Bible are we told that government should take one man's money by force of law and give it to another man."[150]  That is not a new thought among the preachers of the gospel of property. Pat Robertson showed the way:
God's order recognizes the sanctity of private property. The eighth commandment, "You shall not steal" means that the God of Jacob forbids a citizen to take what belongs to another citizen. . . . In God's order there are no schemes of wealth distribution under which government forces productive citizens to give the fruit of their hard-earned labors to those who are nonproductive.[151]
There are, happily, exceptions. Rev. David Beckman and Rev. Gary Cook, of Bread for the World, opposed cuts in food stamps and countered the Perkins-Bauer argument by citing Biblical references to aiding the poor. More to the point, why should a supposed Christian require an express commandment to support programs which help people? Has Christianity been reduced to an excuse not to care, to prevent government from doing what we fail, inevitably, to do adequately as individuals?
Fox "News," the secular arm of the comfortable and uncaring, added mockery to the mix, in the form of an idiotic stunt in which a "reporter" posed as a beggar — for an hour; talk about deep research — then returned to the studio to claim that begging is a sweet deal, that most on the street are phonies, and that those who give are enablers. The mandatory blonde added, no doubt from a wealth of objective data, that other beggars are "scammers," apparently meaning that begging is so profitable, to say nothing of dignified, that it beats work.[152]

How about the minimum wage? Raising it would aid those at the bottom, diminish glaring inequity, lessen the need for food stamps and — here’s comfort to the nervous prosperous — dampen any tendency toward more drastic measures — so it must be universally supported. Well, no. Rep. Joe Barton (R-TX) told the National Journal that he thinks the country should get rid of the minimum wage. "I think it’s outlived its usefulness," he said. "It may have been of some value back in the Great Depression. I would vote to repeal the minimum wage." So would Senator Lamar Alexander. Sen. Marco Rubio declared: "I don’t think a minimum wage law works."[153]  Speaker John Boehner apparently subscribes to the job-destroying argument: "When you raise the price of employment, guess what happens? You get less of it."[154]  His guess (excuse, cover) is more ideology than fact.
Increases in the minimum wage have lagged behind average wages, productivity and increases in income for the top 1%. The last is, strictly speaking, irrelevant, but it is an image of our increasing inequality and the creeping conversion of a democracy into a plutocracy. Had the federal minimum wage tracked increases for the one per centers, it would be $28.34, not $7.25.[155]  Some states, including Washington, have enacted automatic increases, to match inflation. Our current minimum is $9.19, the highest in the country (followed by Oregon and Vermont), and will increase to $9.32 on January 1. A total of nineteen states have minimums above the federal rate. However, many only match it, five are lower and four have no state minimum; raising the federal rate is of critical importance in those states.
Rand Paul doesn’t want to reauthorize extended unemployment benefits. Anything beyond 26 weeks "do[es] a disservice to these workers." Why is that? "When you allow people to be on unemployment insurance for 99 weeks, you're causing them to become part of this perpetual unemployed group in our economy."[156]  Ah yes: it’s such sweet deal that people will snooze in those hammocks Paul Ryan fantasizes about. Actually, unemployment benefits are a stimulant to the economy — more money to spend creates demand — which will create jobs, which in turn will allow more people to return to work.[157]
Meanwhile, corporations make lots of money, pay little in taxes, squirrel cash away overseas and expect taxpayers to bid for their presence, in effect contributing capital but receiving no stock in exchange. (A formerly local company, one of the Dow thirty, symbol BA, is currently the most notorious).

____________________
142. http://walmart1percent.org/family/
143. http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune500/2012/ceo-pay-ratios/ 
 144. http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/poverty-america-affects-residents-article-1.1508965  
145.Michelle Goldberg, "Poverty Denialism," November 25, 2013
146. http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2013/05/23/2053081/congressmans-misuse-of-bible-verse-belies-bad-theology-and-ideology-on-food-stamps/  
147. http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2013/09/25/2677421/how-house-republicans-are-preaching-a-false-gospel-about-food-stamps/
148. http://www.christianpost.com/news/should-christians-support-food-stamps-cuts-depends-on-who-you-ask-105052/
149. http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/10/16/right-wing-christian-liberals-are-the-real-theocrats-because-they-want-to-help-the-poor/
150. http://sojo.net/blogs/2012/01/11/gary-bauer-wrong-about-bible
151. The New World Order (1991), pp. 241-42, emphasis in the original.
152. http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2013/11/21/2977711/john-stossel-poor-people/  
153. http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2013/12/06/3028321/barton-minimum-wage/  
154. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/13/minimum-wage-john-boehner_n_2678362.html
155. http://www.epi.org/publication/bp357-federal-minimum-wage-increase/
156. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/12/08/rand-paul-unemployment-benefits_n_4408046. html  


 
   

Monday, November 18, 2013

November 16, 2013

The following are random thoughts which popped up as I was reading The New York Times on Friday. This occurred at Starbucks, so a latte was involved, my reward for a workout at the gym. (Otherwise I would never be so self-indulgent; that’s my story and I’m sticking to it).
The right has no monopoly on seeing everything falling apart and wishing for older and better times. Any day’s newspaper will confirm to the rest of us the sad state of the nation. For example, gun sales soared in Newtown after the Sandy Hook massacre. In Michigan, a white man shot and killed a black woman who came to his door, apparently seeking help after an auto accident.
We incarcerate more people than any other supposedly advanced country, many for life for minor crimes. Alleged Democrats are deserting the foundering ship of health care reform while Republicans attack a conservative program and pretend that the U.S. has a good health care system.
Serious problems are not an American monopoly. Paul Krugman’s column about European economics demonstrates that others are as ideologically self-destructive as we. I used to think that Germany was better at learning from its mistakes; no longer.
Art sales, bringing incredible prices, demonstrate that some people have way too much money and no taste. The Times’ art reviews also demonstrate the latter, and the ads on pages 2 and 3 demonstrate the former and often both.
One of the sellers in the recent auctions was a hedge fund billionaire whose wholly-owned company has pled guilty to insider trading, illustrating the manipulative nature of the financial sector. Income and wealth are concentrated in the highest percentages of the population, or fractions thereof, at the expense of the rest of the citizens and of the national welfare. Hedge fund managers have bizarre incomes. Actually, the problem isn’t so much their income. If investors are silly enough to allow compensation of that magnitude, often for below-market performance, so be it, but we should not further reward the managers — and rob the public coffers — by taxing their fees at capital gain rates.
There is a source of brief respite from this depressing scene. In May, we saw "Top Hat," in October "Anything Goes": lots of energy, good music, great dancing. It’s impossible not to feel better during and afterward. Note the age of the shows: popular music was better in the Thirties.
Also, we coped better then, with greater challenges, and were more nearly united, despite carping which — so little changes in some ways — included cries of "socialism" and attacks on the President. The latter, though, are more barbaric today. (I seem to have drifted back to the dark side. It doesn’t go away for long).


Monday, November 11, 2013

November 9, 2013
Annex to November 6, 2013
The following is an analysis of the documents most often claimed to support nullification.  
The Federalist
It is argued that Madison, even in the early years, when he was an advocate of strong central government, supported nullification, citing Federalist No. 46.[132]  In the passage relied upon, Madison said this:
Should an unwarrantable measure of the federal government be unpopular in particular States, which would seldom fail to be the case, or even a warrantable measure be so, which may sometimes be the case, the means of opposition to it are powerful and at hand. The disquietude of the people; their repugnance and, perhaps, refusal to co-operate with the officers of the Union; the frowns of the executive magistracy of the State; the embarrassments created by legislative devices, which would often be added on such occasions, would oppose, in any State, difficulties not to be despised; would form, in a large State, very serious impediments; and where the sentiments of several adjoining States happened to be in unison, would present obstructions which the federal government would hardly be willing to encounter.
An unpopular, even unconstitutional, law might be met with opposition: not a startling notion. The disquietude of the people, even their refusal to cooperate, might result. The governor might frown; the legislature might resort to embarrassing "devices." Does this passage, or does Federalist 46, refer to nullification? Well, no.
  
The Virginia Resolutions of 1798 [133]
This document consisted of eight resolutions, the first of which "Resolved, That the General Assembly of Virginia, doth unequivocally express a firm resolution to maintain and defend the Constitution of the United States, . . . and that they will support the government of the United States in all measures warranted by the former." This suggests that Virginia will support the federal government, but only in "measures warranted by" the Constitution. This hints at a theory of state review of the constitutionality of federal laws, but we must see how or whether Virginia used that theory before deciding whether it aids neo-nullifiers.
The second resolution recited that "this assembly most solemnly declares a warm attachment to the union of the states, to maintain which it pledges its powers; and that, for this end, it is their duty to watch over and oppose every infraction of those principles which constitute the only basis of that Union, because a faithful observance of them, can alone secure its existence and the public happiness." In other words, for the good of the union, it proposed to offer an opinion about acts of Congress. Many of us do that regularly.
The third resolution draws the most attention.
That this Assembly doth explicitly and peremptorily declare, that it views the powers of the federal government as resulting from the compact to which the states are parties, as limited by the plain sense and intention of the instrument constituting that compact, as no further valid than they are authorized by the grants enumerated in that compact; and that, in case of a deliberate, palpable, and dangerous exercise of other powers, not granted by the said compact, the states, who are parties thereto, have the right, and are in duty bound, to interpose, for arresting the progress of the evil, and for maintaining, within their respective limits, the authorities, rights and liberties, appertaining to them.
There is states’-rights language here, but its significance depends on the intent of the term "interpose." As we will see, in practice it had a limited meaning, of no aid to neo-nullifiers.
The fourth resolution charged that the federal government had arrogated power "so as to consolidate the states, by degrees, into one sovereignty. . . ." This is a complaint which was as unrealistic in the 1790s as it is now. In any case, it is a political complaint, of no relevance to the nullification issue, except that nullification is offered as a cure for such alleged tendencies. However, nullifiers must justify the theory before deciding how to use it.
The fifth resolution is the heart of the document:
That the General Assembly doth particularly PROTEST against the palpable and alarming infractions of the Constitution, in the two late cases of the "Alien and Sedition Acts," passed at the last session of Congress; the first of which exercises a power no where delegated to the federal government, and which by uniting legislative and judicial powers to those of executive, subverts the general principles of free government . . .
Contrary to the sweeping interpretation given to the Resolutions by advocates of nullification, and contrary to the implications of its bolder language, Virginia limited itself to protesting the Alien and Sedition Acts. 
The sixth resolution objected to restrictions, under the Acts, on "liberty of conscience and the press" in violation of the First Amendment.
In the seventh resolution, the Assembly, again declaring "the truest anxiety for establishing and perpetuating the union of all; and the most scrupulous fidelity to that Constitution," asked for support:
[T]he General Assembly doth solemnly appeal to the like dispositions in the other states, in confidence that they will concur with this commonwealth in declaring, as it does hereby declare, that the acts aforesaid are unconstitutional; and that the necessary and proper measures will be taken by each, for coöperating with this state, in maintaining unimpaired the authorities, rights, and liberties, reserved to the states respectively, or to the people.
The last phrase may excite nullifiers, as it echoes the Tenth Amendment but, like the Tenth, it has no specific meaning. Although the seventh resolution declares that the Acts are unconstitutional, it does not mention nullification and there is nothing in the Resolutions which even hints at it. Virginia expressed its opinion that the Acts were unconstitutional and called on other states to agree. The eighth and last resolution asked the Governor to transmit a copies of the resolutions to the other states.
The Kentucky Resolutions of 1798[134]
Jefferson and Kentucky were less cautious, taking a bold constitutional position in the first resolution. It began by reciting its view of the limitations of the federal government:
That the several states composing the United States of America are not united on the principle of unlimited submission to their general government; but that, by compact, under the style and title of a Constitution for the United States, and of amendments thereto, they constituted a general government for special purposes, delegated to that government certain definite powers, reserving, each state to itself, the residuary mass of right to their own self-government; . . .
Based on that theory, Kentucky asserted, in several ways, a right in the states to determine the limits of federal power; the following is another part of resolution one:
[T]hat whensoever the general government assumes undelegated powers, its acts are unauthoritative, void, and of no force; that to this compact each state acceded as a state, and is an integral party; that this [federal] government, created by this compact, was not made the exclusive or final judge of the extent of the powers delegated to itself, since that would have made its discretion, and not the Constitution, the measure of its powers; but that, as in all other cases of compact among powers having no common judge, each party has an equal right to judge for itself, as well of infractions as of the mode and measure of redress.
Jefferson’s draft included this phrase: "where powers are assumed which have not been delegated, a nullification of the act is the rightful remedy." The legislature omitted that, perhaps thinking it too bold, but its language, "unauthoritative, void, and of no force," and "each party has an equal right to judge for itself," might seem to imply the same conclusion.
The second resolution denounced all federal criminal laws except those specifically identified in the Constitution. It began with a list: "the Constitution of the United States . . . delegated to Congress a power to punish treason, counterfeiting the securities and current coin of the United States, piracies, and felonies committed on the high seas, and offences against the law of nations, and no other crimes, whatsoever. . . ." It added that "the powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people." It concluded that any "acts which assume to create, define, or punish crimes" other than those listed in the Constitution "are altogether void, and of no force" and, for good measure, "the power to create, define, and punish such other crimes is reserved, and, of right, appertains solely and exclusively to the respective States, each within its own territory." That is strict construction carried to an absurd length, in effect claiming that the Constitution should be interpreted as if it were a criminal statute, denying to the federal government the right to deal with any crime not mentioned there. The resolution’s list isn’t complete, as it ignores federal jurisdiction over the District and other federal properties and the territories, but the more important point is that defining crimes and enforcing criminal laws is both a core attribute of sovereignty and a classic case of the application of the necessary and proper clause.  
The purpose of the second resolution’s overreach was to find a basis for declaring the Alien and Sedition Acts unconstitutional, but it also condemned "An Act to punish frauds committed on the bank of the United States."
The third resolution addressed limitations on free speech in the Sedition Act. It expanded on its argument of unconstitutionality and, in so doing, met itself coming back. First, it declared again "That the powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people," and concluded that, since "no power over the freedom of religion, freedom of speech, or freedom of the press being delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, all lawful powers respecting the same did of right remain, and were reserved to the States or the people." Thus far the argument is clear, if not necessarily correct. However, the resolution added that "another and more special provision has been made by one of the amendments to the , which expressly declares, that "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, or abridging the freedom of speech or of the press." If the federal government had no power under the Constitution to abridge freedom of speech or of the press, then an amendment was unnecessary. Therefore the resolution argued either that the First Amendment was superfluous or that such a power could be implied from the original language of the Constitution, exactly what it was attempting to deny.
Resolution four declared that "alien friends are under the [exclusive?] jurisdiction and protection of the laws of the state" because no power over them is mentioned in the Constitution.
The Constitution contains a clause prohibiting the federal government from halting the slave trade before 1808. Resolution five illogically offered up that provision as an argument against the legitimacy of the Alien Act. Resolution six offered a more sensible argument based upon due process. Resolution seven argued against a broad interpretation of the necessary and proper clause.
Kentucky had made sweeping, self-assertive claims; what, then, would it do? It merely asked, in the eighth resolution, that the laws be repealed: "Resolved, That the preceding resolutions be transmitted to the senators and representatives in Congress from this commonwealth, who are enjoined to present the same to their respective houses, and to use their best endeavors to procure, at the next session of Congress, a repeal of the aforesaid unconstitutional and obnoxious acts." 
The ninth and final resolution requested that the Governor send the Resolutions to other states. There followed a long, convoluted statement of reasons for forwarding them which ended with a combination of rhetoric and realism, calling on other states to "concur in declaring these void and of no force, and . . . unite with this commonwealth in requesting their repeal at the next session of Congress."

The Kentucky Resolutions of 1799[135]
Kentucky addressed the issue again the following year; The resolutions were set out in one long paragraph, but there are nine separate propositions. The responses of other states expressed concern over Kentucky’s assertions. Accordingly, it felt the need to reassert its loyalty, so (in resolutions one and two) it did so, hesitantly: "Resolved, That this commonwealth considers the federal Union, upon the terms and for the purposes specified in the late compact, conducive to the liberty and happiness of the several states: That it does now unequivocally declare its attachment to the Union, and to that compact, agreeably to its obvious and real intention, and will be among the last to seek its dissolution."
In the third, it asserted that, if the federal government were "permitted to transgress the limits fixed by that compact, by a total disregard to the special delegations of power therein contained, an annihilation of the state governments, and the creation, upon their ruins, of a general consolidated government, will be the inevitable consequence." This highly unlikely result seemed to be a constant worry.
In the fourth, Kentucky disavowed "the principle and construction, contended for by sundry of the state legislatures, that the general government is the exclusive judge of the extent of the powers delegated to it. . . ." In the fifth and sixth, it reiterated its theory of state adjudication and added the only express reference in any of the Resolutions to nullification: "That the several states who formed that instrument, being sovereign and independent, have the unquestionable right to judge of its infraction; and, That a nullification, by those sovereignties, of all unauthorized acts done under color of that instrument, is the rightful remedy." The last is a paraphrase of the clause drafted by Jefferson for the 1798 Resolutions.
  
In the seventh resolution, Kentucky limited its complaint to the Alien and Sedition Acts but hinted at unilateral action:
[T]his commonwealth does . . . declare, that the said Alien and Sedition Laws are, in their opinion, palpable violations of the said Constitution; and however cheerfully it may be disposed to surrender its opinion to a majority of its sister states, in matters of ordinary or doubtful policy, yet, in momentous regulations like the present, which so vitally wound the best rights of the citizen, it would consider a silent acquiescence as highly criminal.
Having reached the rhetorical brink, Kentucky backed away from it in the eighth resolution:
[A]lthough this commonwealth, as a party to the federal compact, will bow to the laws of the Union, yet it does, at the same time, declare, that it will not now, nor ever hereafter, cease to oppose, in a constitutional manner, every attempt, from what quarter soever offered, to violate that compact. (emphasis added)
The ninth added a rhetorical flourish:
And finally, in order that no pretexts or arguments may be drawn from a supposed acquiescence, on the part of this commonwealth, in the constitutionality of those laws, and be thereby used as precedents for similar future violations of the federal compact; this commonwealth does now enter against them, its solemn PROTEST.
The more ambitious passages may not quite amount to sound and fury signifying nothing, but they certainly provide no constitutional or historical basis for the doctrine of nullification. Virginia and Kentucky expressed their entirely proper opposition to the Alien and Sedition Acts and, especially in the case of Kentucky, indulged in some venting, but the solution was, as it always had been, political.
Report of the Virginia legislature of 1800[136]
Nullifiers claim that Madison’s adherence to states rights and nullification is recorded in a further document, a Report of the Virginia legislature. The Report adopted in January, 1800 (drafted by Madison in late 1799), is a long, rambling document which was prompted by pique at the negative responses by other states to the Resolutions of 1798.
About sixty percent of the 1800 Virginia Report addressed itself to the evils of the Alien and Sedition Acts and, apart from the repetition of some rhetoric in earlier passages, that section is neither controversial nor of much relevance to the present topic.
In the earlier sections, the Report made several statements which are generally supportive of a theory of states’ rights. There is a reference to the Tenth Amendment: "the powers not given to the government, were withheld from it . . . ." The theory of state adjudication is repeated:
The Constitution of the United States was formed by the sanction of the states, given by each in its sovereign capacity. . . . The states, then, being the parties to the constitutional compact, and in their sovereign capacity, it follows of necessity, that there can be no tribunal above their authority, to decide in the last resort, whether the compact made by them be violated; and, consequently, that, as the parties to it, they must themselves decide, in the last resort, such questions as may be of sufficient magnitude to require their interposition.
The Report acknowledged that interposition could be considered an encroachment on the role of the Supreme Court: "But it is objected that the judicial authority is to be regarded as the sole expositor of the Constitution, in the last resort; and it may be asked for what reason, the declaration by the General Assembly, supposing it to be theoretically true, could be required at the present day and in so solemn a manner." In justification, the Report stated that interposition would be limited to "those great and extraordinary cases, in which all the forms of the Constitution may prove ineffectual against infractions dangerous to the essential rights of the parties to it." After all, the Court might make the wrong decision, i.e., uphold a federal law considered in Virginia to exceed constitutional powers:
The resolution supposes that dangerous powers, not delegated, may not only be usurped and executed by the other departments, but that the judicial department also may exercise or sanction dangerous powers beyond the grant of the Constitution; and, consequently, that the ultimate right of the parties to the Constitution, to judge whether the compact has been dangerously violated, must extend to violations by one delegated authority, as well as by another; by the judiciary, as well as by the executive, or the legislature.
What does all of this talk of interposition and decision in the last resort really mean? Despite the foregoing, it doesn’t mean substituting the state’s ruling for that of the Court:
[A] declaration that proceedings of the Federal Government are not warranted by the Constitution, is a novelty neither among the citizens, nor among the legislatures of the states; nor are the citizens or the legislature of Virginia, singular in the example of it.
In other words. there is nothing novel about a protest. Does Virginia claim to be doing more than that? No:
Nor can the declarations of either [citizens or legislatures], whether affirming or denying the constitutionality of measures of the Federal Government, or whether made before or after judicial decisions thereon, be deemed, in any point of view, an assumption of the office of the judge. The declarations, in such cases, are expressions of opinion, unaccompanied with any other effect than what they may produce on opinion, by exciting reflection.
The Resolutions, far from being acts of nullification or even a serious assertion of a right to judge the constitutionality of a statute, are merely expressions of opinion which, it is hoped, will change other opinions.
The expositions of the judiciary, on the other hand, are carried into immediate effect by force. The former [expressions of opinion] may lead to a change in the legislative expression of the general will; possibly to a change in the opinion of the judiciary; the latter enforces the general will, whilst that will and that opinion continue unchanged. (emphasis added to both quotes)
Again, we have sweeping rhetoric reduced to innocuous dimensions: interposition means the emphatic expression of opinion, not substitution for the Supreme Court.
The Report renewed the call of the Resolutions: "Resolved, That the General Assembly . . . finds it to be its indispensable duty to adhere to the [Resolutions], . . . and more especially to be its duty to renew, as it does hereby renew, its protest against ‘the alien and sedition-acts,’ as palpable and alarming infractions of the Constitution."
 
Like the 1798 Resolution, the 1800 Report was a protest.[137]

Notes on Nullification[138]
In this 1836 document Madison repudiated the doctrine of nullification. Nullifiers argued then as they do now that the Virginia Resolutions supported their position, even though Virginia rejected that interpretation. As Madison put it: "Altho' the Legislature of Virginia declared at a late session almost unanimously, that S. Carolina was not supported in her doctrine of nullification by the Resolutions of 1798, it appears that those resolutions are still appealed to as expressly or constructively favoring the doctrine." (There is an argument [139] that Madison, in that comment, meant only to disapprove the South Carolina version of nullification, not the principle. The argument is confused and self-defeating). 
Madison pointed out that the Virginia Resolutions had as their "main and immediate object . . . to produce a conviction everywhere, that the Constitution had been violated by the obnoxious acts and to procure a concurrence and co-operation of the other States in effectuating a repeal of the acts." He muddied the waters by referring to an inherent right of rebellion: "In this view of the subject there is nothing which excludes a natural right in the States individually, more than in any portion of an individual State, suffering under palpable and insupportable wrongs, from seeking relief by resistance and revolution." However, that is an entirely different matter, an extra-constitutional action: "But it follows, from no view of the subject, that a nullification of a law of the U. S. can as is now contended, belong rightfully to a single State, as one of the parties to the Constitution; the State not ceasing to avow its adherence to the Constitution." A state cannot nullify without repudiating the Constitution. "A plainer contradiction in terms, or a more fatal inlet to anarchy, cannot be imagined." Again, "There cannot be different laws in different states on subjects within the compact without subverting its fundamental principles, and rendering it as abortive in practice as it would be incongruous in theory." This seems obvious enough not to require elucidation but then, as now, strange ideas were abroad.
Other writings
On at least two other occasions, Madison rejected the misuse of the Virginia Resolutions and the notion that states had the power to decide whether to obey federal laws. In a letter in 1830, he stated that the Constitution "cannot be altered or annulled at the will of the States individually" and that a "uniform authority of the laws, is in itself a vital principle." He also noted that the debate on the 1798 Resolution "discloses no reference whatever to a constitutional right in an individual State to arrest by force the operation of a law of the U. S." The solution to bad laws is to oppose and repeal them, which is what happened then: "When the Alien & Sedition laws were passed in contravention to the opinions and feelings of the community, the first elections that ensued put an end to them."[140] 
In a letter of 1833, he observed that
The words of the Constitution are explicit, that the Constitution & laws of the U. S. shall be supreme over the Constitutions & laws of the Several States; supreme in their exposition and execution as well as in their authority. . . . The imagination itself is startled at the idea of twenty four independent expounders of a rule, that can not exist, but in a meaning and operation, the same for all.[141]
The contention of today’s nullifiers is more than twice as startling.
Where does a review of all of these documents leave us? The Kentucky Resolutions of 1798 asked its representatives in Congress to work toward repeal of unjust laws. There is one claim of a right of nullification, in the Kentucky Resolutions of 1799 which, however, stated that "this commonwealth . . . will bow to the laws of the Union." The Virginia Resolutions mentioned interposition once, and the Virginia Report used "interposition" or "interpose" several times, but those documents merely protested the Alien and Sedition Acts; the Report disavowed a challenge to the Supreme Court. There are other statements generally supportive of the doctrine of states’ rights, or more specifically of a right of opposition, some of which evaporate on inspection, some of which remain, but none of which proposes nullification, and some of which, being revolutionary, stand outside the compact theory. The nullifiers’ collection of proof texts forms the weakest of reeds on which to lean.

_______________________

132. See Mike Maharrey, "The Blueprint: James Madison’s Advice,"
http://tenthamendmentcenter.com/2013/08/07/the-blueprint-james-madisons-advice/#.UhusN4_n_Vw
133. http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Virginia_Resolutions_of_1798 
134.
http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Kentucky_Resolutions_of_1798 
135.
http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Kentucky_Resolutions_of_1799
136.
http://www.constitution.org/rf/vr_1799.htm
137. The Report used the word "nullification" once, but in a different context, pertaining to an argument by supporters of the Alien and Sedition Acts that they were justified by the common law.
138.
http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/r?ammem/mjmtext:@field(DOCID+@lit(jm090163))   
139. Mike Maharrey, "Spalding, Heritage: Wrong on Nullification. Again."
140. Letter to Edward Everett, August. 28, 1830 http://www.constitution.org/jm/18300828_everett.htm
141. Letter to William Cabell Rives, March 12, 1833 http://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/99-02-02-2703
Posts © 2011-2012 by Gerald G. Day